Showing posts with label marketing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label marketing. Show all posts

Sunday, January 12, 2025

Why I hate the word "deserved".

As I mentioned last week, we're heading into our busy season at work. This year, it's coinciding with Trump's second inauguration and all the crazy-making stuff that we know will go with his return to power. During the first go-round, I was working in an office building two blocks from the White House; I am not the most empathic empath, but to me, the dysfunction and insanity seemed to seep from the White House and permeate the air around it. One of the reasons I decided to retire when I did, in mid 2020, was to escape that madness.

Now the madness is returning to power, and I'm hoping I'm far enough away from it that I won't feel that same ol' anxiety creeping back. 

Here on the blog, I don't plan to comment a lot on the day-to-day craziness. Instead, I'll probably write about peripheral or tangential stuff, which is what I did last time with my several posts on gaslighting. 

Today's post is in that vein. It's not about gaslighting; instead, it's about this idea that people get what they deserve.

***

lightsource | Deposit Photos

I have two problems with the word "deserve". First, it's often deployed as a way to part you from your money. Marketers bait the hook with "You deserve this!" to convince you to spend money on things you don't need. I put it right up there with "pamper yourself" (which always brings to mind an image of swaddling one's bottom with a disposable diaper, but maybe that's just me). We can all think up justifications for impulse buys and impulsive actions: we had a hard day/week/month/lifetime, we need to complete the set, just one more won't hurt, whatever. But the shiny thing we're convincing ourselves that we need might have hidden within it a painful hook in the form of a price we won't want to pay.

That brings me to my second problem with the word "deserve", and it's wrapped up in being judgy.

Every morning for several years, I was sprinkling Penzey's Justice seasoning on my morning eggs and chanting three times, "Trump in prison." It wasn't much, as spells go, and the fact that I was asking for something that I had no direct effect on made it unlikely to succeed. But spellwork sometimes acts as a nudge to make a thing happen. And it seemed for a while like Trump going to prison really could happen; he was facing dozens of criminal counts, after all -- surely some of them would make it through to a conviction. 

Then one by one, each of the four cases bogged down in legal challenges. When Trump won re-election in November, I stopped casting my little daily spell; the chances that he'd face any sort of penalty for his actions, I figured, had pretty much evaporated.

But then, at the eleventh hour, Justice Juan Merchan of the New York Supreme Court came through. As a practical matter, he couldn't sentence Trump to jail time, house arrest, or even community service. But he made damn sure it was on the record: Trump was a convicted felon.

It's not the perp walk and orange jumpsuit I was hoping for, but I'll take what I can get. I'd given up on getting any results. Oh, me of little faith.

But did he get what he deserved? 

The temptation is to say no, right? He should have gone to prison. Others guilty of far less have done time. Our system of justice is skewed to favor those who can afford high-priced lawyers and who can buy, one way or another, their own Supreme Court justices. And so on.

But that way lies bitterness and anger. Is that any way to live? 

Or would it be healthier to acknowledge that the outcome was the best one possible, given the circumstances? Especially since I had no control about any of it from the beginning. I don't work for a prosecutor; I don't work for any court system; I wasn't on the jury. All I had was a jar of Justice seasoning.

***

I've said before, although maybe not here on the blog, that I don't see any point in seeking revenge because people do themselves in by their own actions, and sometimes the Universe even lets you watch. That last part is kind of tongue-in-cheek; I've come to believe that "the Universe" is as much a construct of Western thought as Jehovah or the Force. I'm not a Buddhist, but my ideas may actually be closer to the Buddhist concept of karma, which has less to do with "you get what you deserve" and more to do with the results of the choices you've made in this life and the actions you've taken in response to those choices. Karma also speaks to the intent behind your actions. There's no Sky God of any sort judging you as Good or Evil; whatever happens is just the consequences of your intent.

Donald Trump is a convicted felon. He'll have to live with that for the rest of his life. 

Did he get what he deserved? I can't say. For one thing, it's not my place to judge. 

For another, his life isn't over yet. He won the blue ribbon he was after, but he's still on that hook.

***

These moments of karmic blogginess have been brought to you, as a public service, by Lynne Cantwell. Pace yourselves, guys -- it's gonna be a long four years. 

Sunday, July 28, 2024

The PR machine for Harris.


What a difference a week makes, huh?

CarrotStudios | Deposit Photos

Last week, I went to the movies, looking for a glimmer of hope after President Biden dropped out of the race for a second term. This week, I'm all in for Vice President Kamala Harris. 

The whiplash-inducing turnaround in the mood of Democrats across the country has been striking. And it happened a lot faster than I expected it would. I believe that's due to a masterful public relations plan by the Democratic Party's marketing team -- an effort that caught the Republican Party wholly unprepared.

Look at this timeline, you guys:

  • Saturday, 7/13: Somebody shoots at former President Trump during an outdoor rally in Pennsylvania, nicking his ear, killing a member of the audience, and injuring others. (Cue the "God saved him for a reason" chorus.)
  • Thursday, 7/18: Trump accepts the Republican Party's nomination for president.
  • Thursday, 7/18 (same day): Major news outlets, including Forbes, report that Biden is beginning to think about dropping out. 
  • Sunday, 7/21: Biden announces he's dropping out and endorses Harris. His staff finds out one minute before his announcement, according to NPR. But c'mon, look at the rest of the timeline!
  • Sunday, 7/21: Former President Bill Clinton and former Secretary of State and 2016 Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton endorse Harris.
  • Sunday night, 7/21: 40,000 Black women get on a Zoom call to support Harris.
  • Monday, 7/22: 20,000 Black men do the same.
  • Monday, 7/22 (same day): Former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi endorses Harris.
  • Tuesday, 7/23: Current House Speaker Hakeem Jeffries and Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer endorse Harris.
  • Wednesday, 7/24: Axios runs a story about how the Divine Nine, a coalition of Black sororities and fraternities, is working to support Harris's candidacy with voter registration and education drives. Harris is a member of Alpha Kappa Alpha, one of the Divine Nine. 
  • Wednesday evening, 7/24: President Biden addresses the nation to explain why he's dropping out.
  • Thursday, 7/25: 160,000 White women get on a Zoom call to support Harris, breaking Zoom.
  • Friday, 7/26: As the Republicans begin to sniff huffily that Harris doesn't have former President Obama's support, bam, both Barack and Michelle Obama call Harris to endorse her. The call was obviously staged for social media, but the endorsement is real.
  • Today: Former Vice President and 2000 Democratic presidential nominee Al Gore endorses Harris.
  • Tomorrow night, Monday, 7/29: There's a Zoom call scheduled for "White Dudes for Harris".
Just look at that list. There's been something every day. And along with it were the reports about the cash haul: $200 million, as of today, according to the Harris campaign, which says two-thirds of those donors are new. In addition, 170,000 people have signed up to volunteer for Harris. In a week. 

It'll be tough for the campaign to keep that momentum going for the next three weeks, until the Democratic National Convention starts on Monday, August 19th. But the Democrats had already planned a pre-convention delegate roll call for Wednesday, August 7th, to make sure their candidate made it onto the Ohio ballot (long story). We are also in midst of the dramalamadingdong surrounding Harris's running mate: not only who it will be*, but whether she will announce it this week or wait 'til the convention. All this guarantees the Harris campaign will keep generating headlines.

In response, Trump's campaign first appeared to be flummoxed. It apparently never occurred to them that Biden would actually drop out, so they never developed a Plan B. And their early efforts at coming up with one have been, to say the least, problematic. At least one member of Congress floated the idea of Harris being a "DEI hire", but then congressional leaders told them to quit it. 

Trump himself -- never happy when he's not the center of attention -- told a Turning Point Action group Friday night that if they vote this year and he wins, "It'll be fixed. It'll be fine. You won't have to vote anymore, my beautiful Christians." Which of course prompted outrage from Democrats and the usual gaslighting from Republicans that what he said isn't actually what he meant.

Trump is also having fun with Harris's first name, mispronouncing it as many ways as he can think of. Maybe today's political reporters are too young to remember when the first President Bush used the same tactic on Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein. 

But overall, Trump's ability to recapture the spotlight seems to be faltering. Here he thought he'd just cruise to victory in November as the Chosen One; now he's got a real fight on his hands. With no plan. And just 100 days to go!

***

*The Washington Post has published a quiz so we could all try our hands at picking a Democratic vice presidential candidate. Here's a free link. 

If you care: I got Arizona Senator Mark Kelly, who is actually my second choice; my first is Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, mostly due to geography. Kelly is strong because he's ex-military and a former astronaut, plus his wife, Gabby Giffords, had to resign from Congress after she was shot in the head by a constituent. And Arizona is a battleground state. But it's also a Western state, and usually campaigns go for geographical diversity. Shapiro is also from a battleground state -- one with more electoral college votes than Arizona -- and he has been good at reaching across the aisle. Plus the geographical balance is better.

I'd love to see her pick Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg, if only to watch him wipe the floor with Republican vice presidential candidate JD Vance in a debate. But if you think the "DEI hire" comments are bad now, just think about how loud they'd be with a gay man on the same ticket as a Black woman.

***

These moments of overtly political blogginess have been brought to you, as a public service, by Lynne Cantwell. Make sure to vote!

Sunday, May 17, 2020

Mask up!

I guess you can tell what's at the top of my mind these days, huh? My last several posts have been about COVID-19.

I know I'm not alone -- the virus has pretty much been on everybody's minds around the world. And as I said last week, this business of staying home is wearing thin. Which reminds me -- I have a couple of updates for you on our adventures in apartment living: Remember when I said if our new downstairs neighbors complained again about the noise we weren't guilty of making, I'd offer to trade with them because the folks above us had a newborn? Well, the joke's on me; the baby belongs to the complainers.  And our new upstairs neighbors? Stomper still stomps. And they've had friends over both days this weekend. I'm not gonna be a Karen and report them, but I'm annoyed. Social distancing isn't a joke, people!

And that brings me to the subject of today's post, which is the claim made by some folks that requiring them to wear masks in public violates their constitutional rights.

I've just discovered that the National Constitution Center in Philadelphia has produced a number of podcasts about this and other challenges to the government's response to COVID-19. (By the way, the National Constitution Center is a nonprofit, not a government agency.) In the first podcast mentioned at the link, they talk about why requirements to wear masks don't fall foul of the Constitution. TL;DR: The Founding Fathers had a lot more experience with epidemics than we do today, and quarantine was a universally recognized way of handling them. Not only do the rules and regulations we've been under lately not violate our constitutional rights, but they're actually helping us to preserve our inalienable right to keep living.

But some people need more persuasion.

As I'm sure you've heard, the fabric masks we're wearing everywhere now aren't designed to keep us from getting sick ourselves, but to keep us from spreading germs we have to others. And as I'm sure you've also heard, COVID-19 spreads most readily for a couple of days before symptoms appear -- assuming they ever do. So for someone to say, "I'm not gonna wear a mask! I feel fine!" is pretty dumb. Just because you're not feeling sick right now, it doesn't mean anything. You could still be a walking disease vector.

But apparently for a lot of folks (or maybe a relative handful of really noisy folks), that kind of altruistic appeal falls on deaf ears.

So what we need is to find some way to get through to them, the way we have on another public health issue: seatbelts.

When I was a kid, we didn't have seatbelts in cars. Zero, zip, nada. Parents routinely let their kids ride on their laps or in the back of the family station wagon or -- horrors! -- in the bed of the family pickup truck. All without wearing any kind of restraints. It's a wonder any of survived.

But even after seatbelts became mandatory equiment in new cars in 1968, there was a lot of resistance to wearing them. My dad used to say he'd seen people survive accidents by being thrown clear of the wreck, which wouldn't have happened if they'd been wearing a seatbelt. As late as 1980, only 11 percent of people were doing it. States then began to mandate seatbelt use and eventually allowed police to stop and ticket drivers who weren't wearing them without observing any other violations.

At last, states were getting drivers' attention. But the decades-old slogan, "Buckle up - it's the law," needed work. It was North Carolina that came up with the keeper in 1993: "Click It or Ticket."

What I'm saying is we need a P.R. campaign for mask wearing, and it needs a catchy slogan. I've seen a couple of suggestions on Facebook over the past few days, but it wasn't until I saw this meme today that I realized we had our keeper.


Got your attention, didn't it? Feel free to share it far and wide. And kudos to the anonymous meme-maker.

***
These moments of attention-getting blogginess have been brought to you, as a public service, by Lynne Cantwell. And remember: #MaskItOrCasket

Monday, November 6, 2017

That post-conference high.

I came home with a reading list...
It happens to me every November. I leave town for a writing conference for a few days, and come home all fired up about writing more books and, uh, somewhat less than fired up about returning to real life.

You're hearing from me a day late this week because last night -- or more accurately, very early this morning -- I came home from three days at the 20 Books to 50K conference in Las Vegas. It was my first time in Vegas, and it was both more and less than I expected it to be. But I'll leave the impressions of my trip for another time. Tonight I'd like to talk a little bit about what this conference is all about, and why I skipped this year's World Fantasy Convention to attend.

The conference name is somewhat self-explanatory: the idea is that if you write books in a popular genre and market them properly, you can expect to be making $50,000 a year by the time you've published 20 books. As someone who has just released her 18th book, I found the concept intriguing.

And as an indie author, I was getting less and less out of attending the World Fantasy Convention. It's a meetup for professionals, mostly, who either are chasing a contract with a traditional publisher or who already have one. So while the panels are often interesting and give me food for thought for my own writing, the emphasis behind the scenes is on schmoozing with editors and agents, neither of which -- as an indie -- I'm interested in.

Anyway. I didn't go into the 50 Books conference knowing much beyond what I explained above. What I was hoping for was a blueprint for how the indies who are making money at their craft got where they are. While I didn't get a straightforward answer, as the weekend progressed I got closer to the Big Picture.

First, you need to publish a lot of books each year, and for that you need to write fast. There were several presentations on methods for outlining a book, because it's quicker to write a story when you know where you're going with it. You also need to create characters who readers will fall in love with and want to read more about. Then your cover needs to fit in with others in your genre, your blurb needs to be well crafted, and your book itself needs to be professionally edited.

Next, you need to market it well, and for most authors these days, that means shelling out for advertising. There were several presentations on developing advertising campaigns for both Facebook and Amazon (and I bought books on those subjects written by Michael Cooper and Brian Meeks, two of the presenters at the conference). Another presentation talked about the strategy of doing a rapid release: you release four books, one each week, for four weeks straight. That takes an enormous amount of planning ahead, both for advertising buys and for writing time. But with four titles out at once, they work together to boost you up the sales lists at Amazon -- and the more books you sell, the more money you make.

Some of these concepts were new to me, but some are things we've been talking about at Indies Unlimited for years. (K.S. Brooks and I literally cheered when one of the presenters said his first question about any book cover is how it looks in thumbnail size.)

To sum up, organizers Craig Martell and Michael Anderle did a bang-up job pulling the conference together. And I'm going to be doing a lot of thinking over the next few weeks about how best to deploy some of these strategies next year. Stay tuned...

***
Just before I left for Vegas, I pushed the "publish" button on Maggie at Moonrise. With that, the Transcendence trilogy is complete. I'll pull together an omnibus version pretty soon, but in the meantime, enjoy the new book -- and thanks in advance to those of you who have already bought a copy. You're my new best friends.

***
These moments of bloggy enthusiasm have been brought to you, as a public service, by Lynne Cantwell.

Sunday, October 25, 2015

Confessions of a marketing skeptic.

So here we are, in week two of my test run for sharing my blog posts as Facebook Notes. It seems to be as good a time as any to make a confession: This is basically the only marketing-type thing I've done for my books in months. Why? Because I have an innate suspicion, bordering on irrational fear, of anything that has to do with marketing.

There, I said it. And I apologize in advance to my friends who work in marketing, because the rest of this post is going to be about why this is so.

For starters, I came up through journalism. It's hard to believe now, but in those days journalists thought themselves above any involvement with filthy lucre. Yes, we did our jobs and got paid for them -- but we were supposed to be discerning about the topics we covered. If we were asked to write about a new store or a new product, it had better have something more interesting going on than just being new. It had to be unique, or very nearly so. The redevelopment of a decrepit retail block? We're in. A mac-and-cheese box whose perforated, thumb-sized "open here" button actually worked? We'd like to talk to the inventor. A product that would keep one's shoes from coming untied during the course of a day? We'd be all over that. (Am I the only grownup who has trouble with her shoes? Even if I double-knot my Keens, they untie themselves in a matter of hours.)

Anyway, the point is that we had standards against running stories that amounted to unpaid infomercials. (That's one big reason why so many news releases end up in the trash: the hook is too weak. If there's no real news in your news release, it's going in the circular file.)

Sometimes it was someone from the sales department who would try to sell us on doing a story on his/her client's new something-or-other. Unfortunately for the client, the same rules applied: No hook, no story. And "cool new store in town that's going to buy a lot of advertising from us if you put it on the news" was, unfortunately, not a hook. Sorry/not sorry.

From news, I jumped into the simple living movement. And among that movement's tenets -- besides downsizing your life and reducing your footprint on the earth -- is keeping an eagle eye on your discretionary spending. Don't buy something just because your neighbor bought one; analyze your spending habits and stop buying stuff you don't need; buy the store brand if the quality's the same; kill your television; and so on. These things were pretty much second-nature to me, as my parents grew up in the Great Depression. And I never made a fabulous salary in radio, so I was doing a lot of them anyway, out of necessity.

Fast-forward to today: I've let up on simple living and I no longer work as a journalist. But I still have the sort of inquiring (all right, maybe cynical is a better word) mind that asks what's so new about this thing and do I really need to spend money on it.

And yet here I am, writing novels, which are pretty close to the top of the "stuff no one needs" pile, and asking complete strangers to take a flyer on them. Karma sucks.

Plus, to get my name out there so that people will know about my books, marketing is a necessary evil. But now I'm doing business with people whose messages I've spent decades resisting, and I am skeptical of all of them. Will Marketer X give me the return on my investment he/she claims? (Doubtful, in most cases.) How much is Marketer Y relying on me to get the word out about the promotion I'm paying him money for? (Crowdfunding sites, I'm looking at you.) Why does Marketer Z insist that I must use a particular blogging platform/book distributor/etc., even though other marketers argue for a different one? Whose pockets are being lined by all this advice, and how?

Last fall and winter, I put a fair amount of time and money into marketing, and didn't get much in return. There are a number of reasons why I've pulled back since then, the Denver saga being one of them. But I'm not planning a big push for any of my books this fall -- despite the fact that A Billion Gods and Goddesses will be out in the next week or so, and I expect to release a Pipe Woman's Legacy set for Kindle just before Thanksgiving.

Which is why I'm counting this blogging experiment as marketing. It's another avenue to get my name out there -- and a fairly unique one right now. And it's free.

Anybody else feel the same push-pull about marketing that I do, or am I the only one?

***
These moments of skeptical blogginess have been brought to you (on multiple platforms!) , as a public service, by Lynne Cantwell.

Sunday, May 4, 2014

Effective Frequency, or: Why dollars spent on ads almost never equal sales revenues.

I can’t count the number of times I have heard indies talk about getting a return on their investment when it comes to advertising. Most people consider an ad successful only if they make more money from sales of their books than the ad cost them.

It’s undeniably great when that happens. But that’s not what marketing is for. Marketing is not for selling stuff – at least, not directly. It’s for making your brand so familiar to consumers that they will decide they need whatever it is you’re selling.

A single ad does not familiarity make. There’s an old chestnut in the the marketing business that it takes seven contacts with a prospective customer before you will see any results. In general, someone needs to see your novel seven times before they’ll decide to buy. The technical term for this is effective frequency.
There’s actually some dispute whether the “seven times” rule is still true. Thanks to the intertubes, we’re so overwhelmed with marketing messages nowadays that it probably takes even more impressions to, uh, make an impression. One blog post I read while preparing this article suggests the new number is 13. Although big numbers aren’t new; back in 1885, a guy named Thomas Smith wrote a book called Successful Advertising in which he claimed it takes 20 views of an ad before it makes a dent:
  • The first time people look at any given ad, they don't even see it.
  • The second time, they don't notice it.
  • The third time, they are aware that it is there.
  • The fourth time, they have a fleeting sense that they've seen it somewhere before.
  • The fifth time, they actually read the ad.
  • The sixth time they thumb their nose at it.
  • The seventh time, they start to get a little irritated with it.
  • The eighth time, they start to think, "Here's that confounded ad again."
  • The ninth time, they start to wonder if they're missing out on something.
  • The tenth time, they ask their friends and neighbors if they've tried it.
  • The eleventh time, they wonder how the company is paying for all these ads.
  • The twelfth time, they start to think that it must be a good product.
  • The thirteenth time, they start to feel the product has value.
  • The fourteenth time, they start to remember wanting a product exactly like this for a long time.
  • The fifteenth time, they start to yearn for it because they can't afford to buy it.
  • The sixteenth time, they accept the fact that they will buy it sometime in the future.
  • The seventeenth time, they make a note to buy the product.
  • The eighteenth time, they curse their poverty for not allowing them to buy this terrific product.
  • The nineteenth time, they count their money very carefully.
  • The twentieth time prospects see the ad, they buy what is offering.
Personally, I think Mr. Smith went a little overboard. But I thought his most interesting point was number 10: asking friends and neighbors what they’ve heard. Word-of-mouth is the single most successful marketing you can get. And how do you get word-of-mouth recommendations? Why, from putting your name in front of prospective customers seven (or 13 or 20) times.
And even then, you have to get lucky. If luck didn’t play a part in it – if it was all about just throwing cash at advertising – then every book traditional publishers have ever advertised as the next bestseller would have been one. And we all know how that has worked out for them.

(Originally published at Indies Unlimited and reprinted here in the author's hope -- likely in vain -- that indie authors who see it again will get the message.)

***
These frequent moments of effective blogginess have been brought to you, as a public service, by Lynne Cantwell (who is repeating her name here in an effort to help search engines remember it!).